5 Best Crib Mattresses (2017) – Buyers Guide And Review

Are you going to be a new parent soon and you’re in the lookout for baby room essentials? Or is a second or third baby coming and you just want to keep the crib? If you say “yes” to both questions then you definitely would want to put crib mattress on the top of your to-buy list as it is as important as the crib. Remember, the crib wouldn’t be so comfortable if there’s no cushy mattress for your infant to lie in. Also, during the first few months of your baby’s life, he or she will spend more time sleeping than awake and even when he or she’s awake, he or she will be lying in bed most of the time so you have to make it a priority that these special months are at the highest comfortability for your little one.

Types of Mattresses

A Crib mattress is an essential thing to buy for your baby to sleep in. So before we choose the best crib mattress, let us first know the types of mattresses.

Innerspring Mattresses are coils that are covered with padding, foam, and fabric. High-quality cushioning and better-gauge steel are considered to be more expensive and heavier but they are durable.

Foam Mattresses on the other hand are light and often come in between 3 and 6 inches. If you are going to choose this option for your baby, make sure to choose the heavier kind that is firm and resilient when you press a hand on it. If it’s too soft, it can conform to your baby’s shape thus will create a risk for suffocation and SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome) hazard.

Organic Mattresses are made out of all-natural materials such as wool, cotton, coconut fibers, plant-based foam, food-grade polymers or natural latex. They can be more expensive compared to others but for some parents, these are considered to be the safest option as they claim that other mattresses contain chemicals that could harm babies.

Breathable Mattresses are getting more popular these days. These mattresses are made of materials that allow the baby to breathe freely even if his face is pressed against it.

Factors To Consider When Buying A Crib Mattress

The very first factor to consider when you are going to buy a crib mattress is how firm the mattress is. The more firm, the better. Though the mattress may be too stiff for you, your baby will properly adjust to it. As a tip, press on the center and at the edges of the mattress and make sure it should not follow the shape of your hand and should snap back quickly.

Next, the crib mattress needs to fit right in the crib. There should be no space in between the side of the crib frame and the mattress to ensure there wouldn’t be an entrapment or suffocation hazard.

Another important factor is density, high density foam is recommendable so it would be firm enough to keep your infant safe while he or she is sleeping. If the packaging does not indicate the density, check out the weight instead. For innerspring mattresses, the number of coils is equated with firmness as well as the gauge of the wire. So a lower gauge mattress means it has a thicker wire which means it’s firmer and stronger. Choose a mattress with at least 135 coils, with 15.5 gauge or lower.

Resiliency is another significant factor in choosing a crib mattress and faster resiliency is recommended. To test, push your hand down into the middle of the mattress and take it off after a couple of seconds, does it quickly regain shape? If it takes a long time to maintain the shape, the baby may have a difficult time to change position. There are foam crib mattresses though that are two-stage or dual firmness – firm side for infants and soft side for toddlers.

You also need to check out venting of the crib mattress. Make sure there are small holes on the mattress’ sides that let air flow in and out. Remember, the more vent holes, the better the mattress smells.

Another is cleaning. Traditional ones require spot-cleaning only while others have removable covers that you can machine-wash. Lastly, mattress covers. Choose double or triple laminated ticking reinforced with nylon for better water resistance. This will be more resistant to holes, tears and soggy diapers.

Now that we have established the important buying factors of crib mattresses, let’s now review 5 Best Crib Mattresses available today.

Drawing Tablet Price Dimensions Hypoallergenic
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress $58.99 52.5 x 27.5 x 5.5 inches Yes
Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress $35.18 51 x 27 x 5 inches Yes
Colgate Eco Classica III $180.99 51.7 x 27.5 x 6 inches ?
My First Premium Memory Foam Crib Mattress $80.99 51.6 x 5 x 27.2 inches Yes
Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress $105.75 51.6 x 27.2 x 5 inches Yes
9 Total Score
5 Best Crib Mattresses (2017) - Buyers Guide And Review

5 Best Crib Mattresses (2017) - Updated 2017. The ultimate crib mattress buyer guide and reviews.

User Rating: 2.8 (2 votes)

Here are the Top 5 Best Crib Mattresses We Found:


Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

 

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

VISIT SITE

Price: $58.99

Dimensions: 52.5 x 27.5 x 5.5 inches

The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress is not only affordable but also features high-density thermos-bonded core which offers firm support and will keep your baby crib mattress lightweight and easy to maneuver. It also has a waterproof cover which wipes clean easily and is especially great for night time calls. You don’t have to worry about whether it fits your crib as this crib mattress will fit perfectly into standard cribs and toddler beds. It’s certified free from phthalates and lead and has met the standards for low-chemical emissions, assuring you that your baby is safe and comfortable, thanks to its GREENGUARD GOLD certification. It has also met federal flammability standard 16 CFR 1633 without the use of potentially harmful chemicals.

PROS:
  • Hypoallergenic
  • High density thermo-bonded fiber core provides firm support
  • Lightweight and durable for long-lasting use throughout your child’s development
  • Vinyl cover is waterproof and wipes clean easily
  • Free of phthalates and lead
  • This mattress has achieved GREENGUARD GOLD Certification

CONS:
  • Didn’t fit snugly to the crib
  • Sags easily


 

back to menu ↑

Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

VISIT SITE

Price: $35.18

Weight: 12 lbs

Dimensions: 51 x 27 x 5 inches

Thickness: 5”

Dream on Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress is another crib mattress you should definitely check out. Since it has met the 16 CFR 1632 /1633 Federal Flammability Standards and ASTM Standards, you are assured that your baby will be sleeping safe. It is also free from phthalates and lead and has a 10-year limited warranty.

Now this crib mattress is lightweight and is made of 80 interwoven heat tempered coils which offers firm and excellent support. It also features 6-gauge steel border wire around the perimeter of the mattress and 2 Hypoallergenic layers that provide cushioned comfort for both infants and toddlers. It also has an airflow pocket which keeps the mattress fresh without the need of small metal vents. It is also antibacterial and a waterproof lock stitched binding will prevent mold, mildew and odor.

Dream on Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress comes with a phthalate and lead free, triple laminated waterproof cover that is stain-resistant which helps protect against liquids leaking inside. It wipes clean with mild soap and water and its reversible design allows you to choose a brown cloud print or a white side.

PROS:
  • Lightweight; 80 interwoven, heat tempered coils offers a firm foundation and excellent support
  • 6-gauge steel border wire around perimeter of mattress
  • 2 Hypo-allergenic layers offer cushioned comfort for infants and toddler
  • Airflow pocket helps keep crib mattress fresh without the use of small metal vents
  • Antibacterial, waterproof lock stitched binding helps prevent mold, mildew and odor from seeping inside like cotton binding allows
  • 16 CFR 1632 /1633 Federal Flammability Standards
  • Phthalate and lead free, triple laminated waterproof cover is stain-resistant

CONS:
  • Seam ripping out after a couple of months use
  • Loud and flimsy


 

back to menu ↑

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib mattress, Organic Cotton Cover

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib mattress, Organic Cotton Cover

 

VISIT SITE

Price: $180.99

Weight: 9.4 lbs

Dimensions: 51.7 x 27.5 x 6 inches

Colgate Eco Classica III crib mattress is known for its Dual Firmness design which allows you to flip the mattress easily when your child transitions from infant to toddler stage. It is high-quality and lightweight with orthopedic style dual firmness. It fits all standard size American baby cribs and toddler beds.

It has a certified organic cotton cover with a waterproof backing which lets nothing into the mattress. The foam in this mattress is also CertiPUR-US guaranteed which certifies it is safe and high-quality. The foams are also eco-friendly as they are made of non-food plant oils which replaced the petroleum based oils.

Colgate EcoClassica III crib mattress passes all federal and state requirements for flammability and chemical composition and is GREENGUARD certified to have no harmful air emissions. Lastly, this is made by Colgate, a renown brand who has been making mattresses trusted by parents for over half a century.

PROS:
  • Certified Organic Cotton Cover
  • Eco Foam Infused with Plant Oils
  • CertiPUR certified safe foam
  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified for no harmful emissions
  • Dual Firmness For Use Through Toddler Years
  • Light weight for easy sheet changes

CONS:
  • Not firm, but hard
  • No stitching that says organic


 

back to menu ↑

My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress with Plush Removable Waterproof Cover

My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress with Plush Removable Waterproof Cover

 

VISIT SITE

Price: $80.99

Weight: 11.9 lbs

Dimensions: 51.6 x 5 x 27.2 inches

Our My First Premium Memory Foam crib mattress is comfortable and comes with square corners for snug fit. The CertiPUR-US certified premium memory foam firm crib mattress provides a safe and restful night’s sleep for your baby. Because it is memory foam, the mattress is quiet and won’t make noises when baby moves like the old traditional foam crib mattress with plastic vinyl covers. It also features a soft velour removable crib mattress cover that is waterproof and washable.

Our My First Premium Memory Foam crib mattress is also made without ozone depleters, mercury, lead or any other heavy metals. It is also made without formaldehyde or phthalates regulated by the Consumer Product Safety Commission. Lastly, it is hypoallergenic and comes with a 10-year warranty.

PROS:
  • Baby mattress measures 51-5/8″ x 27-1/4″ x 5″ and fits all standard cribs
  • Baby crib mattress is constructed of premium CertiPUR-US certified flexible polyurethane foam
  • The removable crib mattress cover is soft, washable and waterproof
  • Baby mattress meets and exceeds federal flammability and CPSC standards
  • Hypoallergenic crib mattress is mite-proof, anti-microbial, phthalate and lead free

CONS:
  • Not standard size
  • Very strong smell


 

back to menu ↑

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress

 

VISIT SITE

Price: $105.75

Weight: 8.3 lbs

Dimensions: 51.6 x 27.2 x 5 inches

Sealy Soybean Foam Core crib mattress uses renewable soybeans to create a foam core which provides exceptional firmness and durability for both babies and toddlers. With renewable soybeans grown in the USA and even comes with a waterproof, wipe-clean cover, this crib mattress has a high density core with added cotton cushioning in order to give a balanced sleeping atmosphere for your little one. CertiPUR-US Certified , high-density foam provides this a durable and hypoallergenic, firm mattress.

Its pearl embossed cover is waterproof and you can easily wipe it clean with mild soap and water or a simple baby wipe. Its lock-stitched binding prevents liquids from seeping into the mattress and prevents allergens from clinging to the mattress.

This crib mattress is Greenguard Gold certified for indoor air quality and low chemical emissions to help create a healthier and better sleeping environment for your baby.

PROS:
  • Soy based foam-core offers improved durability over conventional foams and uses renewable resources resulting in the use of less crude oils
  • Lightweight to make changing bedding a breeze
  • Waterproof, reinforced pearl-embossed cover
  • Square corner design for snug fit in standard cribs
  • Lock-stitched binding prevents leaks from seeping inside
  • CertiPUR-US approved foam for durability and air quality
  • A cotton wrap for a premium level of comfort
  • Greenguard Gold Certified for a healthier indoor environment
  • Voted America’s Best Brand for Baby and recipient of the Women’s Choice Award 2013-2016

CONS:
  • Sinks after several months
  • Noisy


9 Total Score
5 Best Crib Mattresses (2017) - Buyers Guide And Review

5 Best Crib Mattresses (2017) - Updated 2017. The ultimate crib mattress buyer guide and reviews.

User Rating: 2.8 (2 votes)
back to menu ↑

Conclusion

All of the products included in our list are definitely of high quality, and each one received 4-5 star ratings and reviews.

However, out of the 5 best crib mattresses reviewed, the number one spot would definitely go to Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress By Sealy. First and foremost, it has been voted America’s Best Brand for Baby and recipient of the Women’s Choice Award 2013-2016 which means it definitely is the best among the many different brands of crib mattresses.  One reason for that is it’s made out of a soy based foam-core which guarantees improved durability and even uses renewable resources resulting in the use of less crude oils. Another thing, it does provide snug fit so you can be assured that your baby is safe. And while it may have minor issues such as sinks after several months or it could be noisy for some, the important thing here is it’s comfortable for your baby to rest and it’s lightweight for you to flip over during your infant’s transition to toddler.

Please rate this review

What did you think of our list of the best crib mattresses? Do you use any of these mattresses personally? Let us know your thoughts and leave a comment below.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply